“Have you ever killed an animal?” I asked Amy as we stood in our kitchen.
“No,” she replied.
Neither had I, except accidentally, with a vehicle. In fact, I dislike killing anything living, even flies, which I generally try to shoo out of the house rather than swat.
The question had arisen because I had just offered to drown a badly injured kitten found in our yard.
A couple days ago, when we arrived home, our dog Brisa and a neighbor’s dog had cornered a young cat that had apparently ventured onto our property. We had adopted Brisa off the streets about a year earlier. I noticed the little creature lying in the grass, staring forlornly at us. I scolded Brisa away, and she slunk toward me submissively.
We suspect she came from the property above ours. Our neighbors there keep many animals, and more than once they have tossed dead ones over onto our land. We know they do away with unwanted litters of puppies and kittens. A young cat raised among their dogs would have had little reason to fear ours. And had we carried her, broken, back up the hill, we knew they would not have taken her.
The cat was a pretty little thing, white and yellow, and unable to move. We carried her to our patio table and examined her. There was no visible blood, but her fur was matted and disheveled, suggesting a violent struggle. She had sensation and movement in her front legs and paws, but her hindquarters were immobile. Her tail hung limp, flopping when touched.
“She has a broken back,” I said.
That was when I offered to drown her. The words surprised even me.
Drowning unwanted kittens and puppies is not uncommon in the villages around us. Many animals are never spayed or neutered, and the resulting litters can become more than families are willing or able to care for. We know neighbors who have resorted to drowning unwanted offspring, sometimes repeatedly. It is a harsh reality of village life, one I have never been comfortable with. Perhaps knowing this practice made the idea come so readily to mind. But there was a difference: I was not thinking of disposing of an unwanted animal. I was confronting what seemed to be a hopelessly injured creature, and wondering whether ending her suffering might be the most merciful thing to do. Yet the idea of taking the lovely cat’s life, even out of mercy, troubled me deeply.
Amy objected immediately. “No. We’re not doing that.”
We wrapped her in a blanket and made her as comfortable as we could. She spent the night quietly, responding gently when touched around her ears, but otherwise remaining immobile. Yesterday, Amy took her to our veterinarian. An X-ray was offered, but I was convinced that the damage was permanent. When Amy called to ask what I thought, I said no. The veterinarian put her to sleep.
We have been a little angry with Brisa.
But what does she know of wrongdoing? She is a dog, following instincts older than any human notion of right and wrong. She cannot comprehend our sadness, or why the little creature she chased should matter so much to us.
And so we find ourselves in the strange position of grieving one innocent animal while loving another who helped bring about its death.
Today, I dug a small grave beneath the trees. Placing the creature in the hole, we stood beside her for a few last moments, admiring her beauty. The earth received the kitten that we named Little Lilly, as it receives all living things in their time.
And Brisa, who knows nothing of death as we understand it, will come to us with her familiar trusting eyes, asking only to be loved.
And we will love her.


























